Studia Theologica

Patience: an exercise in spiritual maturity

Abstract

Patience is examined as a theological and spiritual virtue in contrast to the impatience and irascibility characteristic of contemporary society, which is marked by a fast pace and instant gratification. Taking as its starting point God’s long-suffering revealed in Holy Scripture, through the Holy Fathers such as Maximus the Confessor, Isaac the Syrian and Dumitru Stăniloae, and in the liturgical life of the Church, patience emerges as a means of participating in the divine life and a path to deification.

Contemporary society is characterised by acceleration, immediacy and an obsessive focus on efficiency. Technological progress, globalisation and digital culture have profoundly reshaped people’s relationship with time, actions and attitudes, giving rise to a mindset of constant urgency. In this context, impatience is no longer merely an individual weakness, but a structural feature of life, with major social and spiritual implications, the effects of which are linked to irritability and a lack of attention to the problems of others. The impatient person perceives external obstacles – people, situations, limitations – as sources of disruption to their own will, reacting with irritation, impulsiveness or aggression (whether physical or verbal). Thus, impatience fuels irritability, which in turn reinforces a permanent state of discontent.

This interdependence between impatience and irascibility reflects a crisis of patience accompanied by a failure to understand its theological and spiritual significance. Patience is no longer perceived as a virtue, as a way of participating in God’s work over time, but is reduced to mere psychological tolerance or a form of undesirable passivity. In the absence of this perspective, suffering, delay and unfulfilled expectations are experienced exclusively as failures, not as moments that provide an opportunity for spiritual growth.

At the same time, a lack of patience hinders the practice of love for one’s neighbour and undermines inner peace. Patience, on the other hand, is the virtue that becomes an opportunity for spiritual growth.

A lack of patience hinders the practice of love for one’s neighbour and undermines inner peace. Patience, on the other hand, is the virtue that provides an opportunity for spiritual growth.

A close look at Orthodox spirituality reveals that patience is not merely a moral virtue required of humankind, but a divine attribute, revealed in the economy of salvation and experienced by humankind as a work of divine love. God’s patience expresses the way in which He relates to created freedom, to the Fall and to the history of salvation, being inseparable from mercy, love and faithfulness.

Holy Scripture assures us that God is ‘long-suffering’ (Exodus 34:6)1; yet this patience is directed not towards tolerating sin, but towards man’s return to communion with God, and by no means towards ignoring or despising His goodness: ‘They have despised the riches of His goodness, and His forbearance, and His long-suffering, not realising that the goodness of God leads you to repentance’ (Romans 2:4).

In the Old Testament, God’s patience is particularly evident in relation to the disobedience of the chosen people. The history of salvation, as recorded in Holy Scripture, can be read as a history of God’s patience towards human disobedience and sin. God endures sin not because He accepts it, but because He respects the freedom of the individual and awaits the return of sinners, which is why the prophets interpreted the postponement of punishment not as weakness, but as an expression of God’s desire to allow time for repentance (Jonah 4:2; Jeremiah 15:15). Thus, patience is not the opposite of divine justice, but its salvific manifestation over time. It should be noted that God’s patience does not compromise the immutability of the divine nature: ‘God, being by nature impassible, shows Himself long-suffering towards us through the economy of love, not undergoing change, but working for our salvation’, teaches Saint Maximus the Confessor 2, whilst Saint Athanasius the Great emphasises that God does not change in relation to human sin, but it is man who changes in relation to God’s constant goodness 3.

Patience is, therefore, God’s continuous waiting for man’s return to communion with Him, in a full manifestation of man’s freedom, as Saint Silouan the Athonite emphasised: ‘The Lord has great patience with us, because He loves us; and love does not coerce, but waits’4.

A model of patience in the Old Testament is Job, says Saint James the Apostle: ‘You have heard of Job’s patience and have seen the outcome the Lord intended’ (James 5:11). Job has become the symbol of the faithful man who does not break under the burden of suffering. St John Chrysostom observed that Job’s suffering “did not overcome him, but exalted him, for his patience became an example to all who willingly accept trials”5). Through patience, Job maintained his hope in God, even when his senses and reason demanded immediate answers. Saint Isaac the Syrian saw a contemplative dimension in Job’s patience: “He who endures like Job does not renounce God, but keeps his heart alive, awaiting His mysterious work and learning not to judge by appearances”6. This perspective shows that authentic patience is linked to humility, to trust in divine providence and to the recognition of human limitations in judging the causes of suffering.

…genuine patience is linked to humility, trust in divine providence and the recognition of human limitations in judging the causes of suffering.

The full revelation of this long-suffering of God is realised in the person of Christ the Saviour, Who took on the human condition, suffering and death, in order to deify human nature, first ontologically and then through the working of Grace, in those who are united with Him: ‘The Word of God was united with human nature so that, through this union, human nature might become divine through grace’7 Through Christ the Saviour, God has not only shown His patience, but sets it forth as the path to perfection. ‘The long-suffering’ of the Son of God has become a model for those who will believe (1 Timothy 1:16), for: ‘He took our infirmities upon Himself and bore our sorrows’ (Isaiah 53:4). Patience was linked to kenosis and revealed the saving meaning, foreshadowing the Saviour Christ’s taking up of the cross.

Thus, in the person of Christ the Saviour, God’s patience became visible and personal. Whilst in the Old Testament divine patience was known through oikonomia, ‘The Lord is gracious and merciful, slow to anger and abounding in steadfast love’ (Psalm 102:8), in Christ the Saviour this was lived out not merely as a passive endurance of suffering, but as a free acceptance, inseparable from His total entrustment to the Father, for the destruction of sin and the salvation of mankind.

The Son of God not only speaks of the Father’s long-suffering, but also embodies it. He is ‘the image of the invisible God’ (Colossians 1:15), which implies that all the virtues attributed to God are personally manifested in the earthly life of Christ the Saviour. Saint Dumitru Stăniloae emphasised the personal nature of God and the fact that all divine attributes are lived out in relationship. His patience is, therefore, not merely a virtue, but the historical manifestation of God’s way of being towards humankind. The ‘recapitulation’ of human nature in Christ also involved the assumption of patience as a way of relating to human weakness and sin. Saint Dumitru Stăniloae emphasised that ‘Christ endures not only suffering, but also the rejection, unbelief and hatred of humankind, without ceasing to love them. This is the supreme form of saving love’8

The Son of God not only speaks of the Father’s long-suffering, but also embodies it. His patience is, therefore, not merely a virtue, but the historical manifestation of God’s way of being towards humankind.

In Holy Scripture we see that the Saviour’s patience was manifested not only in the Passion, but throughout His entire ministry: in His relationship with His uncomprehending disciples, with the hostile Pharisees, and with the fickle crowds. It culminated on the cross, where patience became crucified love, for ‘He could have lost the world, but chose to endure for its sake’9 The cross represents the culmination of saving patience. The Son of God did not avoid suffering, nor did He cut it short through divine power, but He endured it in complete obedience; for this reason, Saint Isaac the Syrian saw in this a revelation of divine love: ‘The Cross is the fruit of God’s patience with the world and its sins’10. The Saviour endures His Passion ‘to the very end’ (John 13:1). ‘Christ endures man’s rejection to the very end, yet never ceases to love him; this is the supreme form of divine patience’11, teaches Saint Dumitru Stăniloae. This perseverance in obedience reveals the dimension of patience as a Christological act—by no means one of resignation, but a deliberate one, for “the Lord suffered not out of powerlessness, but of His own will, so that through His patience He might heal our corruption”12.

Thus, the human will was restored and brought to the capacity for free communion with God. ‘Through His patience in His sufferings, the Word healed the human will of disobedience’13; He overcame sin, healed the human will and opened the way to salvation, through which man participates in the loving and patient life of God, so that ‘the Church lives by the patience of Christ, Who continues to bear the weaknesses of His members’14. Having entered into the logic of loving patience, which does not avoid the cross but transforms it into a source of life, ‘the patience of Christ the Saviour does not humiliate, does not coerce, but heals’15.

Embracing the logic of loving patience, which does not avoid the cross but transforms it into a source of life, “the patience of our Saviour Christ does not humiliate, does not coerce, but heals”.

That is why human beings are called to reflect God’s long-suffering in their own lives, both in relation to their own weaknesses and to their neighbour 16. For the Christian life, patience becomes the concrete way of taking up the cross. Without patience, the cross is experienced as absurdity; when borne with patience, it becomes a place of encounter with God, following the Philokalia model.

In the Philokalia, patience is one of the fundamental virtues of the spiritual life, precisely because it has its source in God. Man is called to be patient because God is patient first. Evagrius Ponticus links patience to the knowledge of God: ‘He who has come to know God endures all things with joy, knowing that God endures ceaselessly for his salvation’17

In the Philokalia, patience is one of the fundamental virtues of the spiritual life, precisely because it has its source in God. Man is called to be patient because God is patient first.

Ascetic patience is therefore not resignation, but participation in God’s way of being. Saint Isaac the Syrian expresses this participation in profoundly theological language: ‘Just as God endures without becoming angry, so too does the one who has come to know Grace endure without disturbance’18 At the same time, the Saviour’s patience has become the measure and criterion of the authenticity of the spiritual life, for ‘he who endures tribulations with gratitude follows in the footsteps of Christ’19; and ‘if you do not endure as Christ does, you do not yet know Christ’20. From the patristic and Philokalian perspective, this patience is not merely an object of theological contemplation, but a norm of life and a path to deification for the believer, as Saint Maximus the Confessor teaches: ‘he who has attained perfect love endures all things, like God’21.

In order to attain perfection, the Church reveals itself to be the privileged place where God’s long-suffering is made present, active and tangibly perceptible in the lives of the faithful.

In the Church’s worship, God does not constrain human freedom, but offers Himself ceaselessly, awaiting the believer’s response. This divine ‘waiting’ is an expression of His patience, which extends throughout the liturgical year—a time of patience and sanctification— during which God gives Himself to man not instantaneously or coercively, but in accordance with the rhythm of his spiritual growth. The structure of the seven divine offices, the vigils and the Divine Liturgy reflects the long-suffering patience of God, Who ‘arranges all things in time, according to each one’s measure’, leading creation ‘from the beginning towards perfection’22.

Participation in liturgical life fosters in the faithful an inner disposition of patience, in response to God’s patience. In this sense, the liturgical experience is not merely an expression of divine patience, but also the setting in which this patience is embodied within the Church. Patience thus shapes the entire spiritual journey. Fasting, vigil and repentance are acts that require time and perseverance. Moreover, within the Church community, each person learns the ascetic discipline of patience, but also learns to bear with the weaknesses of others and to live love as a sacrifice, with Saint Isaac the Syrian emphasising that ‘love does not hasten healing, but awaits it with tears and hope’23; for true love is always patient. That is why Saint Paul the Apostle urges the members of the Christian community to ‘bear one another’s burdens’ (Galatians 6:2), indicating that patience towards the weaknesses of one’s neighbour is a form of participation in the sacrifice of Christ. Patience thus becomes ‘the mother of consolation, and he who endures inherits joy’24.

The joy that springs from patience is a profound spiritual reality. Patience creates the space in which Grace can work unhindered, transforming accepted suffering and waiting into an experience of meaning and of the divine presence. From this perspective, joy appears as “the fruit of the Spirit, together with love, peace and patience” (Galatians 5:22). St Paul the Apostle expresses this connection when he states that ‘tribulation produces perseverance; perseverance, character; and character, hope’ (Romans 5:3–4). Joy is, therefore, the fruit of spiritual maturation, of journeying through time without losing faith. Saint Isaac the Syrian emphasises that ‘patience is the foundation of true joy, for it gives birth to peace of heart’25), indicating that joy is not the opposite of suffering, but its transfiguration. Saint Maximus the Confessor states that ‘He who endures tribulations becomes a partaker of future joy and of the knowledge of the divine mysteries’26). Patience becomes inseparably linked to eschatological hope: ‘By your patience you will gain your souls’ (Luke 21:19).

The joy that springs from patience is a profound spiritual reality. Patience creates the space in which Grace can work unhindered, transforming accepted suffering and waiting into an experience of meaning and of the divine presence.

In Christ, the joy that springs from patience takes on a Paschal dimension. The Cross, borne in obedience and patience, opens the way to the Resurrection, and the joy that follows is not external to suffering, but its saving consequence. Saint Maximus the Confessor shows that ‘he who endures sufferings for Christ becomes a partaker of His joy, even in this life’27 This joy is a foretaste of the Kingdom of Heaven, where he will experience directly an ‘inexpressible and glorious joy’ (1 Peter 1:8), as the fruit of steadfast communion with God.

This spiritual joy reveals the presence of God in the heart of the One who has shown Himself to be long-suffering and who, previously, revealed, as the chosen fruits of patience: inner peace, steadfast hope and sacrificial love.

We find this spiritual synergy in the hymns of the Triodion, where patience is presented as ‘co-operation’ with fasting: ‘You have shown me, O Lord, that long-suffering and fasting are a path to salvation’28 In the Canon of Great Lent, Saint John of Damascus shows that ‘fasting of the body is the beginning of patience, and patience opens the heart to the knowledge and love of God’29

From an eschatological perspective, we understand that impatience hinders the purity of the heart and disturbs the peace of the soul, for, as Saint John Chrysostom says, ‘whoever is hasty and does not wait humbly remains a stranger to Grace’30; impatience indicating a failure to grasp the depth of Grace’s work.

Patience therefore remains essential for the participation in Grace, as a form of steadfastness in virtue, being closely linked to the purification of the mind, to tranquillity and to participation in the uncreated energies of God. A key aspect is the relationship between patience and the enlightenment of the mind. The mind, troubled by passions and the haste of desires, cannot receive the work of Grace in a pure manner. Therefore, an inner stillness is required, acquired over time through patience, which, in this sense, becomes a criterion of discernment and a shield against spiritual error.

Patience thus becomes the environment in which Grace works, deepens and bears fruit. It is the concrete expression of the faith that God works over time, in secret, so that man may gradually become a partaker of eternal life, not through compulsion, but through communion.

The workings of this virtue shine through in the spiritual life like a discreet yet essential thread that links man’s ascetic endeavour to the descent of divine Grace, rather than as a form of resistance to anxiety and burnout.

In its truest sense, it is the steadfastness of the heart in awaiting God’s work—without demands, without haste and without agitation. From this perspective, it becomes the criterion of spiritual maturity, which makes possible the gradual realisation of the sharing of divine Grace.

  • 1

    “The Lord, the Lord God, merciful and gracious, slow to anger and abounding in steadfast love” (Exodus 34:6).

  • 2

    Saint Maximus the Confessor, Replies to Thalassius, 59, PG 90, 609C.

  • 3

    Saint Athanasius the Great, Against the Greeks, 40, PG 25, 80B.

  • 4

    Saint Sophrony Sakharov, Saint Silouan the Athonite, Essex, 1999, p. 327.

  • 5

    St John Chrysostom, Homilies on the Book of Job, Homily II, in PSB, vol. 19, EIBMBOR, Bucharest, 1997, pp. 55–59.

  • 6

    Saint Isaac the Syrian, Words on Asceticism, Word 37, Deisis, Sibiu, 2000, pp. 183–185.

  • 7

    Saint Maximus the Confessor, Ambigua, 5, in Philokalia, vol. III, EIBMBOR, Bucharest, 1981.

  • 8

    Saint Dumitru Stăniloae, Orthodox Dogmatic Theology, vol. II, Bucharest, 2003, p. 189.

  • 9

    Saint Isaac the Syrian, Words on Asceticism, in The Philokalia, vol. X, trans. D. Stăniloae, Bucharest, 1981, p. 392.

  • 10

    Saint Isaac the Syrian, Ascetic Sayings, Saying 27, trans. Saint D. Stăniloae, Bucharest, 1981.

  • 11

    Saint Dumitru Stăniloae, Jesus Christ or the Restoration of Man, IBMBOR, Bucharest, 1993, p. 214.

  • 12

    Saint Athanasius the Great, On the Incarnation of the Word, 25, in PG 25, 192.

  • 13

    Saint Maximus the Confessor, Ambigua, 42, in PG 91, 1345.

  • 14

    Ioan I. Ică Jr., The Canon of Orthodoxy, vol. II, Sibiu, 2008, p. 214.

  • 15

    Constantin Coman, The Power of the Word, Bucharest, 2011, p. 121.

  • 16

    Jean-Claude Larchet, The Therapy of Spiritual Illnesses, Sophia, Bucharest, 2001, p. 214.

  • 17

    Evagrius Ponticus, Chapters on Prayer, 95, in the Philokalia, vol. I, p. 92.

  • 18

    Saint Isaac the Syrian, Sayings, 51, in the Philokalia, vol. X, p. 401.

  • 19

    Saint Mark the Ascetic, On the Spiritual Law, 142, in The Philokalia, vol. I, p. 211.

  • 20

    Saint Sophronius of Sakharov, Saint Silouan the Athonite, Essex, 1999, p. 341.

  • 21

    Saint Maximus the Confessor, Chapters on Love, IV, 77, in The Philokalia, vol. II, p. 102.

  • 22

    Saint Maximus the Confessor, Ambigua, 10, in Philokalia, vol. III, translated by Saint Dumitru Stăniloae, published by Orthodox Biblical and Missionary Institute, Bucharest, 1981, pp. 103–106.

  • 23

    Saint Isaac the Syrian, Words on Asceticism, Word 90, Deisis Editions, Sibiu, 2000, pp. 412–414.

  • 24

    Saint Isaac the Syrian, Words on Asceticism, Word 64, trans. Fr. Dumitru Stăniloae, Deisis Publishers, Sibiu, 2000, pp. 298–300.

  • 25

    Saint Isaac the Syrian, Words on Asceticism, Word 34, trans. Saint Dumitru Stăniloae, Deisis Publishers, Sibiu, 2000, pp. 165–167.

  • 26

    Saint Maximus the Confessor, Chapters on Love, I, 27, in The Philokalia, vol. 2, EIBMBOR, Bucharest, 1981, pp. 67–68.

  • 27

    Saint Maximus the Confessor, Chapters on Love, IV, 78, in The Philokalia, vol. 2, EIBMBOR, Bucharest, 1981, pp. 142–143.

  • 28

    Saint Andrew of Crete, in the Triodion, EIBMBOR, Bucharest, 2005, p. 134.

  • 29

    Saint John of Damascus, in the Triodion, EIBMBOR, Bucharest, 2005, pp. 112–115.

  • 30

    St John Chrysostom, Homilies on the Epistle to the Romans, Homily IX, in PSB, vol. XXX, EIBMBOR, Bucharest, 1999, pp. 146–147.